EXplainable AI (XAI) offers a wide range of algorithmic solutions to the problem of AI's opacity, but ensuring of their usefulness remains a challenge. In this study, we propose an multi-explanation XAI system using surrogate rules, LIME and nearest neighbor on a random forest. Through an experiment in an e-sports prediction task, we demonstrate the feasibility and measure the usefulness of working with multiple forms of explanation. Considering users' preferences, we offer new perspectives for XAI design and evaluation, highlighting the concept of data difficulty and of the idea of prior agreement between users and AI.